Scott Kaiser, of counsel with the law firm Degan, Blanchard, and Nash.
Jordan Amedee, Partner with the law firm Degan, Blanchard, and Nash.
This Sound Off Louisiana blog has been in existence for 11-1/2 years and, to date, we have reported upon numerous defamation lawsuits filed during that timeframe. This past week, on November 10th, 12th, and 13th, however, history was made in that we began observing and will be reporting upon an actual trial entailing a defamation case which, heretofore, we have refrained from publishing the first word on.
The case entails former Alcohol and Tobacco Control (ATC) Commissioner, Murphy Painter, on whom we concluded this eight-episode series on April 13, 2022 during which Painter explained in great detail exactly what all he endured during and immediately after his tenure in that position.
We have periodically published features on Painter’s civil defamation suit against former Louisiana Inspector General Stephen Street, Jr., with that litigation now in its 15th year with two recent court hearings entailing it in 19th JDC and another hearing scheduled for December 7, 2026 at 9:00 a.m. in newly-appointed Judge William Jorden’s courtroom.
The case upon which we’ll be focusing for today’s feature is completely separate from that litigation, and today’s case entails fallout from the 2019 election for Ascension Parish President in which Painter was a candidate.
Because we have never published a word on the current case, we want to invite everyone reading this post to spend just 90 seconds getting a fantastic overview of the case via this excellent feature by WAFB (Channel 9 in Baton Rouge) reporter Rylee Kramer:
11/10/26: WAFB’s excellent overview of the case.
Understandably, WAFB has tons of material to cover, so Kramer has made only a couple of appearances at the trial, but Sound Off Louisiana’s Burns has attended all but about two hours (he took an early lunch on Friday, November 13, 2026) so, what we’re going to do is give a witness-by-witness recount of some of the witnesses’ testimony highlights of the trial thus far along with providing a little commentary regarding the attorneys and Judge Michael Kirby:
Murphy Painter (on witness stand all day Tuesday and part of the day Thursday):
Painter testified that he had a long tenure with the Ascension Parish Sheriff’s Office having served as Chief Deputy under former Sheriff Harold L. Trudico for 14+years until June 30, 1988 when he stepped down after a falling out with Trudico, whom he (along with numerous audience members with whom we spoke and who worked with Trudico) described as little short of a falling over drunk. Painter would subsequently run unsuccessfully for Sheriff against Trudico in 1991.
Painter also testified that Jeff Wiley became Chief Deputy after Painter, and he strongly indicated that Wiley obtained that role solely because he married the daughter of Hickley Waguespack, Sr. (Linda), who served as Ascension Parish Sheriff for 24 years leading up to Trudico’s tenure as Sheriff. Painter felt Wiley’s obtaining of that position wasn’t equitable, especially given that Painter had, “propped Trudico up through five elections.”
Painter further testified that Wiley and Painter squared off in the 1995 Sheriff race with Painter losing to Wiley by “a half a percentage point.” Painter also testified entailing his astonishment that 75 percent of Ascension Parish voters voted in that election, which he stated had never happened before nor since that particular election.
Painter testified that, during that 1995 election, he distributed a campaign push card entailing former Ascension Parish Sheriff Deputy and retired LSP Trooper Onner Ray Farris having been indicted for the alleged molestation of six juveniles under the age of 12. From the just-linked 10/21/95 Advocate article:
Molestation charges dismissed *** Defendant agrees to complete pre-trail intervention program
Publication date: 10/21/1995 Page: 3-B;4-B Section: NEWS Edition:
Byline: VICKI FERSTEL
Ascension Parish prosecutors agreed Friday to dismiss sex molestation charges against former sheriff’s deputy and retired state trooper Onner Ray Farris if he completes a two-year pre-trial intervention program.
The decision came one day after a state judge ruled that a widely distributed political flier describing Farris as an indicted child molester was insufficient grounds to delay his trial.
The ruling cleared the way for Farris, 50, to go on trial next week for molesting a teen-aged relative. He faced further prosecution on sex charges involving two other juvenile girls and a juvenile boy.
The young woman who was to be Farris’ accuser had he gone to trial next week was among family members and neighbors assembled in Assistant District Attorney Robin O’Bannon’s office Friday afternoon for a telephone interview about the surprise agreement with Farris.
The young woman, 17, said Farris sexually molested her four times when she was between the ages of 10 and 12.
The young victim’s mother, now 40, claimed Farris molested her when she was 12 or 13 years old.
“The evidence is such we probably could have gotten a conviction,” [Ascension Parish Assistant DA O’Bannon, who remains at the DA’s Office to this day] said.
The intervention program, administered by the District Attorney’s Office, does not require judicial approval, O’Bannon said.
Farris, currently working for a trucking firm in Iberville Parish, also stood accused of child molestation charges involving another relative and a girl in the neighborhood.
Farris faced prosecution, too, on a count of indecent behavior several years ago with a juvenile boy. That boy is an uncle of the neighborhood girl Farris was accused of molesting.
The uncle, now 27, is serving time in a state prison after pleading guilty last year to forcible rape of his niece, O’Bannon said.
The uncle was 16 at the time of the alleged indecent behavior incident involving Farris, O’Bannon said.
Painter testified that, “there is nothing in the Code of Criminal Procedure that makes Pre Trial Intervention a part of a criminal record.” Painter also testified that his understanding was that Farris would be required to move out of state for good, but he indicated that Farris nevertheless managed to, “weave his way back into the local community a year later.” Painter further testified that the Pre Trial Intervention document, “would not have been written if I had been Sheriff!”
[Sidebar: As Burns listened to Painter’s testimony of the Sheriff Department’s handling of the Onner Ray Farris matter, he could not help but have a flashback to our extensive series concluding on September 14, 2023 on former Ascension Parish Sheriff Captain C. J. Matthews’ own quest to become Sheriff wherein he outlined very similar latitudes afforded to former Ascension Parish Sheriff Deputy Fred Corder].
Painter testified that he and “nephew” Dustin Lee Wambsgans attempted to arrange a meeting between Painter and Dustin Clouatre (pronounced Clew-Watt) to potentially obtain Clouatre’s support for a 2019 race for Ascension Parish President which Painter testified that, based on “numerous friends and business associates encouraging me to run,” he had decided to pursue. The reason for the quotations preceding Wambsgans name (i.e. “nephew”) above is that Painter had married Wambsgans’ Godmother, and he had always referred to Painter as “Uncle Murphy” when addressing him.
Ultimately, a meeting between Painter and Clouatre did transpire on or around February 7, 2019, and it is that meeting which ultimately has given rise to this entire litigation.
Painter testified that, despite Clouatre indicating numerous times during their meeting that he was not recording the meeting, Clouatre did in fact record the entire approximate 72-minute meeting, which was played in its entirety during trial.
Painter testified that he began hearing “general rumors” that a damning audio of him was out there, but he stated that he had no idea what the audio could be. He subsequently learned that, his assurances notwithstanding, Clouatre had in fact recorded the meeting and that he gave a recording of the meeting to blogger Wade Petite, who is also a Defendant in the litigation and is representing himself.
Painter succeeded in making the runoff for Parish President against Clint Cointment (pronounced Quit-Maw) with Cointment receiving approximately 42 percent to Painter’s 22 percent.
On October 18, 2019, Petite published an article on his blog (Pelican Post) which referenced Painter in an extremely unflattering light regarding the above-referenced matter entailing the Onner Ray Farris matter referenced above. That publication also included readers’ ability to click on an audio file and listen to an audio excerpt from the Clouatre meeting which strongly indicated that Painter had been willing to look the other way entailing the alleged molestation of six juveniles.
Painter testified that he knew immediately that the tape had been selectively edited to totally and completely change the commentary he made on the tape.
As stated above, the tape is 72 minutes in length, but the segment Petite published was only about 50 seconds with certain critical words edited out.
It is our goal to, in a follow up feature, obtain a photo of the actual quote Painter made on the recording which will include in bold face the words removed from the tape; however, for purposes of this feature, here’s how Painter went about even referencing the Farris incident.
As backed up by the 72-minute recording, Clouatre, who owns numerous businesses in Ascension Parish and also is an insurance agent at Hughes Insurance (which is where the meeting and recording took place) asked Painter why he desired to pursue Parish President rather than Sheriff, and Painter responded to Clouatre’s question by saying that he would not join the “clique” and “cut my wrist” to be in that “clique” and go along with the kind of corruption outlined in the Farris matter. He indicated during his testimony that he was conveying that, because of his adamant stand against that type of corruption, he would not have a realistic chance of winning a Sheriff race because of the apparent fact that such corruption continues unabated at the Sheriff’s Department (to which we would concur based on the Matthews feature we linked above).
In the edited Petite tape, the wording “which I would never do,” was completely removed from the tape, thus making the recording sound like Painter may have been an active part of Farris’ favorably treatment. Painter indicated that such would not have been possible given that he was not even employed at the Sheriff’s Office at the time the Farris matter surfaced in 1993 (recall above that Painter departed on June 30, 1988).
Because the Pelican Post feature was published, combined with follow-up coverage by WAFB publishing the fact that Parish District Attorney Ricky Babin stated that he would have to initiate an investigation on the matter (thus lending credibility to Petite’s distorted publication and altered audio file), continuing his campaign was completely unfeasible, so he withdrew from the race three days later, on October 21, 2019.
Michael Marchand:
Marchand testified that he edited the recording of the Clouatre–Painter conversation. He said that he had previously edited recordings for Petite for other publications.
He stated that he removed Clouatre’s voice from the recording solely at Petite’s direction and did not recall making additional edits to Painter’s own statements. He also noted that he had worked for Clint Cointment’s campaign in 2014–2015.
Former Ascension Parish Councilwoman Teri Casso:
She testified about her prior dealings with Wade Petite and The Pelican Post. She said that a friend told her that Petite wanted her to drop out of the 2015 election; furthermore, if she did not, he would publish something that would hurt her reelection chances. What she feared being published was an email exchange with Petite in which she expressed support for gay individuals to have the right to be married. She testified that she told Painter about Petite’s threat, and Painter replied, “That’s blackmail!”
She explained that she felt comfortable discussing the issue with Petite because it would not affect how she voted on the Parish Council, but she worried about the political fallout.
She stated that Petite had indicated that she may “lose her job” if her supervisor (she worked at an adoption agency and indicated that she “loved her job very much”) uncovered her statement in the email. She stated that she felt the best way to handle the matter was to just tell her supervisor, which she indicated that she did and that he responded, “I’ve always known you were more liberal than me,” and told her not to worry about it. Given that Petite had no ammunition entailing her losing her job, he ultimately declined to publish anything regarding the email.
Former Parish President Kenny Matassa:
He testified about his earlier experience involving recordings published by Wade Petite. In March 2017, Matassa was indicted on an election bribery charge. He was accused of offering political favors to get a candidate (A. Wayne Lawson) to withdraw from a Gonzales City Council race. Petite later published audio recordings that he said captured the alleged bribery attempt. Matassa was ultimately acquitted. Matassa testified that he never pursued a defamation lawsuit over the matter because his attorney did not want to also sue the district attorney. Obviously, any such case would have been futile given the indictment and trial, which was tried by the Louisiana Attorney General’s Office.
Advocate reporter David Mitchell:
We want to start by indicating that prominent media attorney Scott Sternberg entered the courtroom as Mitchell was called to testify (no doubt having provided legal guidance prior to his testimony). Mitchell testified that he was very uncomfortable publishing anything regarding the Petite tape because there were too many unresolved questions. He cited Painter’s use of the word “we” and “our friend” on the recording, leaving it very ambiguous regarding who Painter was even referencing on the audio recording. Mitchell also testified that he’d gone so far as to visit the Courthouse in Donaldsonville to attempt to substantiate these statements made by Painter regarding Trudico on the tape:
Or, or, or the sheriff leaves a bar and goes down the road and runs over some poor black guy on a frickin’ motorcycle and kills him and then tries to frame some woman for running him off the road. And they hide him out for eight hours ‘til he gets sober to take a frickin’ breath test when the law requires that you got to take a frickin’ uh, uh, you got to take a frickin’ blood test.”
When Mitchell was asked why any journalist may be uncomfortable publishing an article given the uneasiness he indicated that he felt toward the Petite article and accompanying recording, he responded, “Because you’ll get sued.”
Mitchell was also asked what impact the removal of the words Petite is assessed as having removed would have on Painter’s quoted words, and Mitchell responded, “You probably would not have a story.” We would take it a step further and state that the word “probably” could be removed from Mitchell’s quotation! Furthermore, publishing a story with those words remaining in the quotation likely would have actually benefitted Painter, and that was obviously the absolute last thing Petite set out to do!
Painter Campaign Manager Michael Beychok:
Beychok testified that pre-primary polling showed Painter had a “clear path to victory,” though he could not guarantee a win. He had been monitoring The Pelican Post’s coverage because the site had previously published unfavorable stories about Painter. After the edited recording was published, he believed the campaign could not recover: “You can’t put a genie back in the bottle, and the genie was out. Everyone was talking about it.” He further testified that the “death knell” was DA Ricky Babin (who was sued by Painter but was subsequently dismissed) making a public statement that he would conduct an investigation (he had a grand jury investigate the matter) and WAFB (Channel 9 in Baton Rouge) covering that fact. He recommended that Painter withdraw from the election, and Painter did so, thus making Cointment the winner by default.
Ascension Parish DA Ricky Babin:
Babin obtained edited clips of the February 2019 recording from Wade Petite (not the full conversation) and treated them as a tip about possible child-rape allegations that needed investigation.
He called Painter in early August 2019 (shortly before qualifying) to ask about the alleged rapes. Babin said the purpose was to gather information about the crimes, not to investigate or target Painter or damage his campaign.
Painter viewed the call as an attempt to discourage him from running. Babin forwarded the material to the Louisiana State Police, which declined to investigate for insufficient evidence. In fact, Babin indicated that then-Colonel Kevin Reeves stated to him that LSP “had no interest” in the matter. We will point out that indication was made, according to Babin, in June of 2019. That timeframe is critical because it was literally about a month after the Ronald Greene matter (May 9, 2019), and we feel certain that Reeves was much more preoccupied with insulating then-Governor Edwards from any fallout on that matter as well as keeping it from blowing up in LSP’s face, which it ultimately did anyway once we broke that whole incident wide open on September 10, 2020.
At any rate, Babin then pursued the matter himself in stating that he felt it was his duty given the seriousness of allegations involving children. A grand jury was convened. That grand jury found no evidence that Painter had participated in any cover-up or that the alleged rapes had gone uninvestigated.
Babin testified that he had no way to know what matter Painter was referencing on the tape because, as we have pointed out, Painter was no longer at the Ascension Parish Sheriff’s Office at the time of the Farris events referenced. He further testified that the number of alleged victims Painter referenced on the tape did not match the actual number of victims in the Farris matter.
Babin also stated that he stood by his handling of the investigation while acknowledging that his office “was not perfect.”
Babin testified in the late morning of Friday, November 13, 2026, and Burns got hungry, so he departed for lunch prior to Babin’s testimony concluding. When he returned from lunch, several members of the audience (some of whom vividly recall Burns’ attendance at Painter’s criminal trial in 2013) indicated that Painter’s attorney, Kim Landry, at one point asked Babin if he realized that giving false testimony to the Court could result in the loss of his law license, to which he reportedly responded (again, Burns was not present to actually hear this but does trust the audience members), “Yes, I am.”
When Babin’s testimony resumed after lunch, it became readily apparent to Burns which aspect of Babin’s earlier testimony Landry was attempting to grill Babin on and ensure he was accurate.
She asked Babin, “You stated in your prior testimony this morning that you began working at the Ascension Parish DA Office in 1996, correct?” Babin responded, “I’ve been with the DA’s Office for 30 years. My math makes me having started in 1996.” Landry then presented him with a copy of his curriculum vitae, which clearly showed him starting with the DA’s Office in 1995, not 1996.
The reason Landry sought to make the distinction is because she was trying to establish Babin being at the DA Office during the 1995 timeframe when the deal was cut with Farris as referenced above. Babin repeatedly stated, “I did not work the Farris case.”
Defendant Dustin Clouatre (Clue-Watt):
Clouatre testified that it was not unusual for him to record conversations in his office. After the February 2019 meeting with Painter, he called Wade Petite, went to Petite’s house, told him about the conversation, and downloaded the recording onto Petite’s phone, while saying he made Petite promise not to do anything with it.
He has said (in trial testimony and earlier under-oath accounts) that he recorded the conversation because he believed Painter was recording him. He has also testified about a prior recording involving former Parish President Kenny Matassa: he showed Petite and another person how to use a recording device but claimed he did not know Matassa would be the subject or that it would be published.
During Painter’s testimony, he indicated that Clouatre adamantly denied even making the recording “for over a year,” but now readily admits that he did make the recording.
Painter’s attorney, Kim Landry, and Clouatre got into a fairly heated debate about the difference between a “conference call” and a “three-way call.” Landry was posing questions about Clouatre’s phone records, and Clouatre indicated that he does not make effort to recall all of his phone conversations and asked Landry if she did. Landry responded, “When it comes to conference calls, I do!” Landry was pointing out a four-way phone call several months after the recording wherein the participants on that call were: #1) Wade Petite, #2) Michael Marchand, #3) Dustin Clouatre, and #4) Parish President (then candidate) Clint Cointment.
Clouatre, an insurance agent, sought to obtain the insurance policy for the parish and, according to Painter, he ultimately obtained that contract with “hundreds of thousands of dollars” flowing to him from that contract.
Clouatre’s testimony will resume upon the trial reconvening on Tuesday, November 17 at 9:00 a.m.
Clouatre is perceived as the lone Defendant because Petite, who is representing himself, according to one witness’ testimony, “derives all of his income from the Pelican Post and much of that from political campaigns.” That income was indicated to not be all that substantial. When Petite cross examined the witness (we’re sorry, but we can’t recall which witness it was and Burns failed to write that testimony in his notes), he asked the witness, “How do you know that?” The witness responded, “Everybody knows it. It’s common knowledge.” Petite has not yet testified at the trial.
So, just to be clear, Clouatre is a named defendant in the suit (along with Petite and the Pelican Post), and claims against other originally named parties (including DA Babin, Parish President Cointment, and Hughes Insurance) were dismissed earlier prior to this week’s trial.
“Nephew” Dustin Lee Wambsgans (called by the Defense but out of order):
We’ve already stated why Wambsgans is loosely referenced as Painter’s “nephew.” Even though Painter is not finished calling his witnesses, Wambsgans was called out of order by the Defense. Wambsgans described Painter as a “close family friend,” and, as we’ve stated previously, he has referred to him as “Uncle Murphy” since childhood (he is 38 years old now).
Wambsgans testified that he too, like Clouatre, was an insurance agent in 2019 and would like to obtain the Parish insurance contract. He testified that he did introduce Painter and Clouatre by providing contact information for Clouatre (and supplying a screen shot to Painter so he would know he’d done so), and that contact introduction subsequently facilitated the meeting between Clouatre and Painter on February 7, 2019. The purpose of the meeting was ostensibly to talk about the insurance contract, which Wambsgans testified that Painter said he (Wambsgans) would, “have a great opportunity to obtain.” Wambsgans indicated that Painter intended to put the contract out for bid, and he could seek to obtain the contract, and that Wambsgans merely sought that opportunity to bid on the contract. Ironically, the 72-minute recording never referenced insurance; however, Painter testified that they discussed that matter in the parking lot prior to him departing the premises.
Wambsgans, again called as a witness for the Defense, did testify that, as Painter became uneasy about a recording being “out there” that reportedly cast him in a bad light, and upon the conclusion of a meal at a local restaurant off College Drive in Baton Rouge (near Wambsgans’ office), Painter embraced Wambsgans in the parking lot of the restaurant and then proceeded to pat him down checking for a recording device. He indicated that he sought to assure Painter that he would never be a part of any effort to discredit Painter. We should point out that there was a point during Petite’s cross examination of Painter where he asked about any patting down in a restaurant, to which Painter responded that there were tons of patrons in the restaurant, and he certainly would not do anything like that in a restaurant.
The above testimony notwithstanding, in the aftermath of the Petite recording being released, Wambsgans testified that at a subsequent meeting at the same restaurant, they had each ordered water to drink and, according to Wambsgans, prior to the water even arriving, Painter stated, “the only thing I want to hear out of you is that you set me up!” Wambsgans then testified that Painter didn’t seem at all believing of his denials of any such set up, and he further testified that Painter “peeled out of the parking lot” in a very angry display.
Judge Michael Kirby:
Judge Kirby is not a sitting elected judge of the 23rd Judicial District Court (which covers Ascension, Assumption, and St. James parishes). He is a retired Louisiana judge who has been appointed ad hoc (specially assigned) for cases, including in the 23rd JDC area. He previously served as a judge on the 25th Judicial District Court (Plaquemines Parish) from 1985 to 1999. He was then elected to the Louisiana Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal, where he served from 1999 until his retirement around 2011. His education includes a B.A. from LSU (1970) and J.D. from LSU Law Center (1973). He was admitted to the Louisiana bar in 1974. Before the bench, he served on the Plaquemines Parish Commission Council (including as President) and in related local roles. After retirement, he has been appointed by the Louisiana Supreme Court to sit ad hoc on various matters.
We have observed Judge Kirby to be extremely courteous to everyone with him even going so far as to apologize for being a few minutes late for the trial’s opening due to traffic and road construction and concluding that opening day by saying, “and I promise to be aware of all of that and be here on time in the morning.” We’ve attended many court hearings in 19th JDC, and we think we can state with extreme confidence that we’ve never heard any Judge in 19th JDC be so professional in committing to everyone in the courtroom his dedication toward being on time for the second day of the trial.
Defense Attorneys Scott Kaiser and Jordan Amedee:
It seems pretty obvious to us that the goal of Kaiser and Amedee is to establish a basis for either of two mitigating factors for Clouatre’s involvement with Petite in this matter to thereby insulate him from liability for defamation.
The line of questioning for cross examination by Kaiser seems to us to have the goal of seeking to sever the actions of Petite (with Kaiser even telling one witness of an acknowledgement of the words being removed from Painter’s quotes) from his (Clouatre’s) own actions.
In other words, they seek to demonstrate that Petite acted alone in his distorted portrayal of Painter and that Clouatre was not a part of Petite’s actions, and they seek to portray that Clouatre didn’t even have knowledge of what Petite would do with the recording.
This is a bench trial, but were it a jury trial, it would seem that a logical question for jurors would be, “Well, why give him the tape at all knowing Petite’s extensive past history of attacking candidates for public office?”
In our opinion, the strongest evidence presented to date by Painter to contradict any perception that Clouatre was unaware of any intent of Petite is that is that four-way phone call in which the participants were: #1) Michael Marchand (who took out the segments of the tape as requested by Petite and removed Clouatre’s voice from the tape), #2) Wade Petite, #3) candidate for Parish President Clint Cointment, and #4) Defendant Dustin Clouatre. Obviously, Clouatre’s alleged denying that he even made the recording for over a year certainly doesn’t help his credibility in trying to establish a severing of his actions with those of Petite.
Also, since Clouatre has testified that recording phone calls is “routine business,” it would seem that a recording of that four-way phone call would exonerate him if he in fact had nothing to do with the subsequent publication of the article to include that damning 50-second manipulated clip, no?
The second angle at which it seems obvious that Kaiser and Amedee are striving for is to establish that Painter was a “public figure” at the time and that actual malice needs to be demonstrated against Painter to establish liability for a defamation case. We draw that conclusion based largely upon Kaiser’s cross examination of Painter. During that cross examination, Kaiser prefaced his questions of Painter by indicating that he had no intention to “embarrass” Painter but had him confirm that he was the former ATC Commissioner, that he’d been indicted entailing that tenure (to which Painter was quick to add the fact that he’d been acquitted by a Petit Jury), and other questions designed clearly to cement the fact that Painter was a public figure. That fact would seem obvious to anyone, and that, in our opinion, is what makes this a very challenging case.
In Louisiana, as in every U.S. jurisdiction, a Plaintiff who is a public official or public figure must prove actual malice to win a defamation claim. This fact comes from the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (1964) and later cases that extended it to public figures (Curtis Publishing Co. v. Butts, etc.). Louisiana courts apply it.
Actual malice means the defendant published the statement knowing it was false or with reckless disregard for whether it was true or false. It is not ordinary ill will, spite, or “malice” in the everyday sense. Public-figure/official plaintiffs must prove it by clear and convincing evidence, not just a preponderance of the evidence.
Private individuals generally only need to prove negligence (failure to use reasonable care in verifying the statement), which is one reason why Matt Bowers went out of his way on video to state in our most recent feature, “last I checked, my name is not on the ballot!” Bowers has indicated a firm resolve to sue those responsible for what he deems as an assassination of his character when he is just an ordinary citizen, in sharp contrast to Daniel Seuzeneau, candidate for St. Tammany Parish Sheriff, who was the subject (along with Bowers) of vicious attack ads assessed as being attributable to folk supporting former LSP Col. Robert Hodges in that Sheriff election. As we have reported, a judge in that matter issued an order for that material not to be published any further than it already had. That runoff election is slated for Saturday, December 12, 2026.
Louisiana treats defamation as a delict (a violation of the law — a tort) under Louisiana Civil Code article 2315. The Louisiana Supreme Court and appellate courts have repeatedly stated that public officials and public figures (including candidates for office) face this heightened constitutional burden. This standard applies whether the case is against media or private defendants and covers statements related to the plaintiff’s official conduct or role in public affairs. It is a Federal Constitutional requirement that State law cannot lower.
In analyzing the above criteria, Petite would seem to have an almost insurmountable hurdle to try and overcome as he presents his defense on the whole matter this week. Nevertheless, as demonstrated in the brief WAFB video above, he has indicated that, during his defense, “the truth will come out.” Petite is expected to frame his defense largely around free speech but, in our opinion, such free speech most certainly does not extend to manipulating an audio file to materially distort what is on that audio tape, and there appears no doubt on anyone in that courtroom’s mind that Petite did exactly that!
Petite actually published the article with accompanying audio file, but tying Clouatre to that action with actual malice toward Painter is more challenging, but given the phone records and the parties involved in that conference call over which Clouatre and Landry got into the heated argument, we think that it is genuinely possible that Painter may be able to clear that hurdle even with it being as high as it is.
Make no mistake, that hurdle is incredibly high as outlined above for public figures to include candidates for public office and the fact that there may be at least some level of doubt as to whether the evidence is “clear and convincing” that Clouatre actively orchestrated Petite’s actions or at least gave his full blessing to it will be aspects which Kaiser and Amedee will be arguing strongly as they present their defense this week. Obviously, as has already been stated at trial, Clouatre did not even request the meeting between he and Painter. We expect Kaiser and Amedee to harp on that fact very strongly as they put on their defense of Clouatre.
Were this not a defamation case with that extremely high bar to meet for a public official, we would not hesitate to say Clouatre would be held liable but, in the end, Judge Kirby should be able to evaluate whether that hurdle, albeit as high as it is, has been cleared in this case.
As we just emphasized, only Judge Kirby can make the assessment regarding both Defendants, and, except for Wambsgans (called out of order), the Defense has not yet put on its case, but one intriguing witness is going to be O’Bannon (the Assistant DA who brokered the plea deal for Farris). Furthermore, Painter still has witnesses to call, and Clouatre should resume testimony upon the trial reconvening.
Plaintiff Attorney Kim Landry:
She only has two more months to serve as an attorney because she was victorious on November 3, 2026 in obtaining her own seat as a 23rd JDC Judge. In our opinion, she has brought her “A game” for this trial, and these first three days have been utterly fascinating to watch unfold. This matter has been ongoing for seven years, and even if Painter does not prevail, it certainly has provided a wide open portrayal of just how incredibly dirty Ascension Parish elections and governmental operations in general can get!
At Sound Off Louisiana, we’re rarely first to report on anything like this matter, but we also report on many matters that the mainstream media never even publishes. We strive to make up for not being first with thoroughness, and we hope that our site visitors believe we’ve done so for this trial through its first three (3) days. We look forward to providing continuing coverage as it resumes on Tuesday of this week.

